Well, I'll start with positives very comfortable warm can't feel any wind easy on and off. Negatives it's about as waterproof as a brown paper bag front pockets easy fill with water so don't leave phones or wallets in them. Takes an age to dry out. Maybe it was the Scottish rain who knows. But wish they would say how long it's waterproof for IE 10 mins or maybe an hour. The first place it gets really wet is elbow area strange. Don't waste you money buy an oversuit.